COMP9331 Lab 1- Tools of the Trade Solution

Exercise 1: Tools of the Trade
Lab Exercise 1: Teools of the Trad

There are 6 labs during this course. For each student, the 5 best performing labs will contribute to your final lab mark.
Objectives:
Get familiar with the basic networking tools: ping, traceroute, ifconfig, netstat, nslookup
Gain insights into evaluating network performance and understanding network topology
Prerequisites:
Week 1 Lectures
Relevant Parts of Chapter 1 of the textbook
Introduction to Tools of the Trade
(https://webcms3.cse.unsw.edu.au/COMP3331/20T3/resources/51942) runping.sh (https://webcms3.cse.unsw.edu.au/COMP3331/20T3/resources/52062) plot.sh (https://webcms3.cse.unsw.edu.au/COMP3331/20T3/resources/52086)
Basic understanding of Linux. A good resource is (http://www.ee.surrey.ac.uk/Teaching/Unix/) here (http://www.ee.surrey.ac.uk/Teaching/Unix/) but there are several other resources available online
Marks: 10 marks
This lab comprises of a number of exercises. Pl note that not all the exercises for this lab are marked. However, you have to submit a report containing answers for all of the lab exercises.
Please attend only in your allocated lab slot.
We expect the students to go through as much of the lab exercises as they can at home and come to the lab for clarifying any doubts in procedure/specifications.
Note: For all your lab exercises you are asked to put a screenshot of your outputs (e.g., graphs, traceroute, dig comments) in your report.
Late Penalty:
The late penalty will be applied as follows:
Note that the above penalty is applied to your final mark. For example, if you submit your lab work 2 days late and your score on the lab is 8, then your final mark will be 8 - 3.2 (40% penalty) = 4.8.
Submission Instructions:
Prepare a PDF document Lab1.pdf with answers to all questions for all exercises. To include other supporting documents, create a tar archive of all the files called Lab1.tar. Submit the archive using give or WebCMS3 interface. You can submit from a lab machine or ssh into the CSE login server. Instructions to ssh into CSE login servers are here (https://taggi.cse.unsw.edu.au/FAQ/Logging_In_With_SSH/) .
1. Put all your files (e.g., Lab1.pdf, output.txt) in a directory lab1.
2. Type “tar –cvf Lab1.tar lab1”
3. When you are ready to submit, at the bash prompt type 3331
4. Next, type: give cs3331 Lab1 Lab1.tar
Please make sure that the tar archive is not corrupted. You can untar (use tar –xvf Lab1.tar) the created archive to check that all the files are intact.
Max file size for submission is 3MB .
COMP9331 students should also use 'give cs3331'
Original Work Only:
OS Compatibility:
Exercise 1: nslookup
Use the nslookup command from the "Tools of the Trade" and answer the following questions:
1. Which is the IP address of the website www.koala.com.au? In your opinion, what is the reason of having several IP addresses as an output?
2. Find out the name of the IP address 127.0.0.1. What is special about this IP address? Exercise 2: Use ping to test host reachability
Are the following hosts reachable from your machine by using ping:
www.unsw.edu.au (http://www.unsw.edu.au)
(http://www.cse.unsw.edu.au) www.getfittest.com.au (http://www.getfittest.com.au) www.mit.edu (http://www.mit.edu)
www.intel.com.au (http://www.intel.com.au)
(http://www.intel.com.au) www.tpg.com.au (http://www.tpg.com.au)
(http://www.telstra.com.au) www.hola.hp (http://www.hola.hp)
(http://www.hola.hp) www.amazon.com (http://www.amazon.com)
(http://www.wikileaks.org) www.tsinghua.edu.cn (http://www.tsinghua.edu.cn) (http://www.tsinghua.edu.cn) www.kremlin.ru (http://www.kremlin.ru)
8.8.8.8
If you observe that some hosts are not reachable, then can you explain why? Check if the addresses unreachable by the ping command are reachable from the Web browser. Exercise 3: Use traceroute to understand network topology
Note: Include all traceroute outputs in your report.
1. Run traceroute on your machine to www.columbia.edu (http://www.columbia.edu) . How many routers are there between your workstation and www.columbia.edu (http://www.columbia.edu) ? How many routers along the path are part of the UNSW network? Between which two routers do packets cross the Pacific Ocean? Hint: compare the round trip times from your machine to the routers using ping.
2. Run traceroute from your machine to the following destinations: (i) www.ucla.edu (http://www.ucla.edu)
(ii) www.u-tokyo.ac.jp (http://www.u-tokyo.ac.jp) and (iii) www.lancaster.ac.uk
(http://www.lancaster.ac.uk) . At which router do the paths from your machine to these three destinations diverge? Find out further details about this router. (HINT: You can find out more about a router by running the Whois command: Whois router-IP-address). Is the number of hops on each path proportional the physical distance? HINT: You can find out the geographical location of a server using the following tool - http://www.yougetsignal.com/tools/network-location/
(http://www.yougetsignal.com/tools/network-location/)
(http://www.traceroute.org) . What are the IP addresses of the two servers that you have chosen. Does the reverse path go through the same routers as the forward path? If you observe common routers between the forward and the reverse path, do you also observe the same IP addresses? Why or why not?
Exercise 4: Use ping to gain insights into network performance
Note: Include all graphs in your report. You need to run the scripts (runping.sh and plot.sh) when you are physically using a lab machine or connected to a CSE server/lab machine using VLAB / VNC client. You need to ensure gnuplot and ps2pdf are available on your system if you are planning to do this exercise on your own machine.
We now use the ping utility to investigate network delay and its implications on network performance. In particular, we will analyze the dependency of packet size and delay.
$ ping -s 22 -c 50 -i 1 www.abc.net > www.abc.net-p50
...
$ ping -s 1472 -c 50 -i 1 www.abc.net > www.abc.net-p1500
and writes the output of the pings to the corresponding files.
Use this script for the following destinations:
(i) www.uq.edu.au (http://www.uq.edu.au/) (ii) www.upm.edu.my (http://www.upm.edu.my) (replacing
www.dlsu.edu.ph (http://www.dlsu.edu.ph/) as the hosting appears to have changed) and (iii) www.tu-berlin.de
(http://www.tu-berlin.de/)
In other words, execute the following commands
$ ./runping.sh www.uq.edu.au
$ ./runping.sh www.upm.edu.my
$ ./runping.sh www.tu-berlin.de
In case you notice one of the hosts above is not responsive, select the following alternate destinations: (i) within Australia ( www.flinders.edu.au (http://www.flinders.edu.au/) , www.unsw.edu.au (http://www.unsw.edu.au/) ) (ii) Asia ( www.smu.edu.sg (http://www.smu.edu.sg) , upd.edu.ph
(http://upd.edu.ph/) ) (iii) Europe ( www.aau.dk (http://www.aau.dk/) , www.uio.no (http://www.uio.no/) )
Note that all delay values reported are in milliseconds (ms) and reflect the round trip time (RTT) between your host and the destinations.
When the runping.sh script is finished for all destinations, you can plot the results using another provided script, plot.sh (https://webcms3.cse.unsw.edu.au/COMP3331/20T3/resources/52086) , as follows:
$ ./plot.sh www.uq.edu.au-p*
$ ./plot.sh www.upm.edu.my-p*
$ ./plot.sh www.tu-berlin.de-p*
If you cannot execute plot.sh, then fix the permissions by executing the following command in the command line:
$ chmod u+x plot.sh
The script plot.sh will produce the following files: destination_delay.pdf, destination_scatter.pdf, and destination_avg.txt for each of the destinations (e.g., for www.uq.edu.au (http://www.uq.edu.au/) we have
www.uq.edu.au_delay.pdf (http://www.cse.unsw.edu.au/~cs3331/www.uq.edu.au_delay.pdf) , www.uq.edu.au_scatter.pdf (http://www.cse.unsw.edu.au/~cs3331/www.uq.edu.au_scatter.pdf ) and www.uq.edu.au_avg.txt (http://www.cse.unsw.edu.au/~cs3331/www.uq.edu.au_avg.txt ) ).
The graph destination_delay.pdf shows how delay varies over time (different colours correspond to different packet sizes), and destination_scatter.pdf shows delay vs. packet size as a scatter plot. destination_avg.txt contains the average (2nd column) and minimum (3rd column) delay values corresponding to each packet size (1st column).
1. For each of these locations find the (approximate) physical distance from UNSW using Google Maps and compute the shortest possible time T for a packet to reach that location from UNSW. You should assume that the packet moves (i.e. propagates) at the speed of light, 3 x 10 8 m/s. Note that the shortest possible time will simply be the distance divided by the propagation speed. Plot a graph where the x-axis represents the distance to each city (i.e. Brisbane, Serdang and Berlin), and the y-axis represents the ratio between the minimum delay (i.e. RTT) as measured by the ping program (select the values for 50 byte packets) and the shortest possible time T to reach that city from UNSW. (Note that
the y-values are no smaller than 2 since it takes at least 2*T time for any packet to reach the destination from UNSW and get back). Can you think of at least two reasons why the y-axis values that you plot are greater than 2?
2. Is the delay to the destinations constant or does it vary over time? Explain why.
3. Explore where the website for www.epfl.ch (http://www.epfl.ch/) is hosted. Is it in Switzerland?
4. The measured delay (i.e., the delay you can see in the graphs) is composed of propagation delay, transmission delay, processing delay and queuing delay. Which of these delays depend on the packet size and which do not?
Comments
  (/COMP3331/20T3/forums/search?forum_choice=resource/51961)
 (/COMP3331/20T3/forums/resource/51961)
 Add a comment
Hi Salli,
I have some question about the IP address geographical location you provided (i.e., http://www.yougetsignal.com/tools/network-location/
(http://www.yougetsignal.com/tools/network-location/) ). For this router:

I remember you mentioned in the lecture last week 'hnl' means Honolulu. But the location tool suggest that the router is in Australia:

So I'm bit confused why that happened, is this because 'hnl' can also represent somewhere in Australia?